Prev 25 of 50 Next
25. MISSOURI: Banana Cream Pie at Scape in St. Louis
The Nutter Butter crust is what makes Scape's banana cream pie stand out from the rest — that, and the banana custard, fresh whipped cream, and caramel sauce AND the caramelized bananas on top. Apparently the chef at Scape took this item off the menu a few years ago because he ate "one a day," but it appears that this scrumptious pie is here to stay now.

The Best Part: Scape's bread pudding is also out of this world.