Maybelline Kissing Koolers
"Since I'm the old lady here—living my pre-teen years in the '80s (meep!)—I have to go with Kissing Koolers. They made their way into my Paula Abdul Straight-Up Life in 1988. I would steal my sister's collection when she was away at parties drinking Purple Passion."—Ann Brady, Executive Editor

Although it's not quite Kissing Koolers, Tarte's LipSurgence Lip Tint ($24) is a nice alternative for those looking for both the tint and the flavor of the discontinued lip color.