Naturistics Sweet Lips Fresh Sqeezed Lip Gloss
"Back in middle school, you wouldn't find me without at least two of these babies tucked into my patent-leather backpack. They smelled like fresh fruit on crack and frankly tasted so good, it was tough not to just lick the stuff right off. Looking back, these tubes were a goopy mess and the color had little staying power, but my friends and I thought they were the best thing going."—Bethany Cantor, Style Editor

If you crave a similar touch of color, try Burt's Bee's tinted lip balm in Hibiscus ($7) for a more grown-up scent.