Simma's Bakery In Milwaukee
Opened in 1982, this Milwaukee staple specializes in cheesecakes and mini-pastries. Try their Peanut Butter Mousse Cups and their award winning cheesecake with a chocolate cake bottom and a blanket of chocolate ganache.

Best Yelp Review: "This is easily the best cheesecake in Milwaukee...If you haven't been in their bakery, I think it's pretty much impossible to walk in there and not get anything extra. I left with a black and white cookies that I proceeded to stuff my face with as soon as I got into my car."